Consider the Source

Mystery firm is election's top corporate donor at $5.3 million

By Michael Beckel and Reity O'Brien

Update (Nov. 5, 4:10 p.m.): This story has been updated to include comment from William S. Rose, Jr., of Specialty Group Inc.

The biggest corporate contributor in the 2012 election so far doesn’t appear to make anything — other than very large contributions to a conservative super PAC.

Specialty Group Inc., of Knoxville, Tenn., donated nearly $5.3 million between Oct. 1 and Oct. 11 to FreedomWorks for America, which is affiliated with former GOP House Majority Leader Dick Armey.

FreedomWorks’ super PAC has spent more than $19 million on political advertising including $1.7 million on Oct. 29 opposing Tammy Duckworth, a Democrat running for Congress in Illinois against tea party favorite Joe Walsh, a first-term incumbent.

The buy was more than four times greater than the group’s previous largest single expenditure.

Specialty was formed only a month ago. Its “principal office” is a private home in Knoxville. It has no website. And the only name associated with it is that of its registered agent, William S. Rose Jr., a lawyer whose phone number, listed in a legal directory, is disconnected.

Rose released a press release Monday saying the company was created to "buy, sell, develop and invest in a variety of real estate ventures and investments."

In the six-page statement, Rose said he was a "disappointed, yet staunchly patriotic, baby boomer" with concerns about the administration's handling of the terrorist attack on the U.S. diplomatic mission in Benghazi, Libya, as well as the Department of Justice's botched "Operation Fast and Furious" gunwalking program.

Consider the Source

Las Vegas Sands Corp. Chief Executive Sheldon Adelson answers questions during a press conference.

Sam Kang Li/AP

Investment managers top list of super PAC donors

By Rachael Marcus and Andrea Fuller

Despite his vast wealth, Sheldon Adelson was not exactly a household name when the Republican presidential primary campaign got under way. But the casino magnate’s multimillion-dollar contributions to a pro-Newt Gingrich super PAC ended that.

Adelson’s support was linked to a shared stance with Gingrich as staunch supporters of Israel. Not quite so well publicized was Adelson’s financial stake in who wins the presidency.

A second Obama term, thanks to the incumbent’s proposed tax policies — could cost Adelson billions if he brought home profits earned at his overseas casinos, according to tax experts.

Since Gingrich flamed out in the primaries, Adelson and his wife Miriam have shifted their allegiance to GOP presidential nominee Mitt Romney, giving the pro-Romney super PAC Restore Our Future $20 million.

With Romney as president, Adelson, the billionaire chairman and CEO of the Las Vegas Sands Corp., could bring his profits home tax-free.

The Las Vegas Sands’ overseas operations account for 86 percent of its revenue from casinos, hotels and shopping, according to its 2011 annual report to the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Sands’ most lucrative holdings are in Macau, a special administrative region in China.

Super PACs like Restore Our Future can accept unlimited contributions from billionaires, corporations and unions and spend the money on ads helping their favorite candidates, thanks to the U.S. Supreme Court’s 2010 Citizens United decision.

Daily Disclosure

This ad from American Future Fund is part of the wave of attack ads that hit Obama over the weekend.

YouTube/Screenshot

Daily Disclosure: Obama slammed with $37 million in attack ads

By Rachael Marcus

In the final weekend before Election Day, President Barack Obama was hit with more than $37 million in attack ads; Romney faced less than $1 million in attacks, according to reports filed with the Federal Election Commission.

Outside spenders dropped roughly $56.3 million on the presidential election in recent days, according to reports filed Friday, Saturday and Sunday. More than two-thirds of the ads are negative, a Center for Public Integrity analysis shows.

On all federal races, outside groups reported over the weekend spending roughly $73.3 million.

The biggest outside spender, not counting party committees and traditional political action committees, was the conservative super PAC American Crossroads, co-founded by GOP strategist Karl Rove. It reported spending nearly $23 million, almost entirely opposing Obama.

In a distant second was American Future Fund, a conservative nonprofit, which reported spending $7.9 million, most of it supporting Romney. Two new anti-Obama ads, “Fed Up” and “Delphi” debuted Friday.

The primary pro-Romney super PAC, Restore Our Future, reported spending $4.4 million opposing Obama. It released the ad “Flatline” on Friday.

Consider the Source

Top Republican donors include, from left, Harold Simmons, Bob Perry and Charles Koch.

AP

Top 5 super PAC donors by industry

Securities and Investments

Rank: 1

Total: $94 million*

Favorite candidate: Mitt Romney

Top donors: Ken Griffin, Paul Singer, Robert Mercer, John Paulson, Joe Ricketts

Donors’ interests: Most favor limited regulation of financial markets and keeping taxes low, particularly on income from investments.

Industry’s interest: Same as donors.

Casinos and Gambling

Rank: 2

Total: $55 million

Favorite candidate: Mitt Romney

Top donors: Sheldon Adelson and family

Donors’ interests: Keeping taxes low on overseas profits that are repatriated to the U.S., strong support for Israel.

Industry’s interests: Removing online gaming restrictions and expanding the visa waiver program (so foreign tourists can more easily come to the U.S. to gamble), according to the American Gaming Association.

Chemical and Related Manufacturing

Rank: 3

Total: $31 million

Favorite candidate: Mitt Romney

Top donors: Harold Simmons and his company, Contran Corp.

Donors’ interests: Simmons’s companies want to eliminate certain environmental regulations that have resulted in millions of dollars’ worth of environmental cleanup costs for Contran subsidiary Valhi Inc. and led to numerous personal injury lawsuits against Valhi subsidiary NL Industries, according to Securities and Exchange Commission filings.

Industry’s interests: Keeping the costs of environmental and safety regulations to a minimum while improving the industry’s image relative to climate change.

Consider the Source

Did super PAC attacks make a difference in 2012 election?

A 2010 U.S. Supreme Court decision opened the door to unlimited spending on elections. Did all that money have an impact on who won?
Here are the 10 most popular general elections in the U.S. Senate and House among super PACs and nonprofits and the results of those elections.
(Results through 10 a.m. ET Thursday on races called by AP.)

NATIONAL

Rank Race Name Total outside spending** % Negative Candidate spending Winner
1 President Barack Obama (D)*
Mitt Romney (R)
$141.5 million
$408.5 million
68.9%
80.5%
$540.8 million
$336.4 million
Obama

SENATE

Rank Race Name Total outside spending** % Negative Candidate spending Winner
1 Virginia Tim Kaine (D)
George Allen (R)
$21 million
$29.8 million
88.6%
93.9%
$18.6 million
$11.5 million
Kaine
2 Wisconsin Tammy Baldwin (D)
Tommy Thompson (R)
$21.6 million
$18.2 million
87.6%
85.5%
$11.7 million
$6 million
Baldwin
3 Ohio Sherrod Brown (D)*
Josh Mandel (R)
$14 million
$20.7 million
84.3%
80.0%
$19.5 million
$12.9 million
Brown
4 Indiana Joe Donnelly (D)
Richard Mourdock (R)
$12 million
$16.3 million
95.9%
74.6%
$3.8 million
$6.8 million
Donnelly
5 Nevada Shelley Berkley (D)
Dean Heller (R)*
$14.6 million
$13.1 million
90.7%
94.0%
$10.2 million
$7.6 million
Heller
6 Montana Jon Tester (D)*
Denny Rehberg (R)
$12.8 million
$11.9 million
87.3%
97.0%
$11.6 million
$7.2 million
Tester
7 Arizona Richard Carmona (D)
Jeff Flake (R)
$8.6 million
$11.7 million
98.4%
68.6%
$4.3 million
$6.7 million
Flake
8 Florida Bill Nelson (D)*
Connie Mack (R)
$4.8 million
$15.2 million
76.2%
64.0%
$12.5 million
$6.3 million
Nelson
9 North Dakota Heidi Heitkamp (D)
Rick Berg (R)
$8.5 million
$7.6 million
88.1%
78.0%
$4.1 million
$4.7 million
Heitkamp
10 Missouri Claire McCaskill (D)*
Todd Akin (R)
$8.2 million
$2.8 million
81.2%
40.0%
$17.4 million
$4.6 million
McCaskill

* incumbent

HOUSE

Rank Race Name Total outside spending** % Negative Candidate spending Winner
1 PA-12 Mark Critz (D)*
Keith Rothfus (R)
$4.1 million
$6 million
76.4%
76.3%
$2.1 million
$1.5 million
Rothfus
2 OH-16 Betty Sue Sutton (D)
Jim Renacci (R)*
$5.2 million
$4.6 million
96.6%
97.0%
$1.6 million
$2.5 million
Renacci
3 MN-8 Rick Nolan (D)
Chip Cravaack (R)*
$5.1 million
$3.9 million
90.8%
95.2%
$536,000
$1.2 million
Nolan
4 IL-17 Cheri Bustos (D)
Bobby Schilling (R)*
$4.3 million
$4.6 million
94.3%
95.6%
$1.4 million
$1.9 million
Bustos
5 CA-7 Ami Bera (D)
Dan Lungren (R)*
$5.3 million
$2.9 million
90.0%
99.2%
$2.7 million
$1.7 million
Bera
6 CA-52 Scott Peters (D)
Brian Bilbray (R)*
$3.6 million
$4.6 million
97.0%
87.1%
$3.5 million
$2.1 million
Peters
7 CA-10 Jose Hernandez (D)
Jeff Denham (R)*
$3.6 million
$4.4 million
93.4%
97.5%
$1.4 million
$2.2 million
Denham
8 TX-23 Pete Gallego (D)
Francisco Canseco (R)*
$4.5 million
$2.8 million
94.2%
95.5%
$1.5 million
$1.9 million
Gallego
9 IL-12 Williams Enyart (D)
Jason Plummer (R)
$3.2 million
$4.2 million
88.5%
95.3%
$733,000
$903,000
Enyart
10 IL-11 Bill Foster (D)
Judy Biggert (R)*
$2.5 million
$4.7 million
99.5%
71.1%
$1.8 million
$1.7 million
Foster

* incumbent

** Total represents combination of outside spending supporting candidate and outside spending opposing candidate’s opponent.

Source: Center for Responsive Politics, Federal Election Commission, Center for Public Integrity analysis. Expenditure totals for 2012 election through Nov. 5. Candidate spending totals through Oct. 17.

Daily Disclosure

President Barack Obama and New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie visit the Brigantine Beach Community Center to meet with local residents, in Brigantine, N.J., following Hurricane Sandy.

Pablo Martinez Monsivais/AP

Daily Disclosure: Conservative outside ads spin Obama’s Sandy response

By Rachael Marcus

With President Barack Obama earning high marks on his response to Hurricane Sandy, conservative outside spending groups and Republicans are seeking to contrast it with charges that he dropped the ball in Benghazi.

Americans for Limited Government’s “Obama Campaign Has Its ‘Perfect Storm’” and Campaign for American Values PAC’s “Obama Has Left Americans Behind” follow the line of attack launched by Michael Brown, the director of FEMA under George W. Bush, who was widely criticized for botching the response to Hurricane Katrina in 2005.

While the new ads do not go quite as far as Brown, who charged the president with acting too quickly on the response to Sandy, they do capitalize on his juxtaposition of the president’s response to Sandy and his response to the terrorist attack on the American consulate in Libya.

Obama was “openly working with New Jersey Gov. Chris Christie during hurricane recovery,” the ALG ad begins. Christie, a Republican with presidential aspirations, heaped praise on the president for his response, which was seen as a hit to GOP nominee Mitt Romney.

“Obama didn’t react to terrorist attacks in Libya the same way he reacted to Sandy,” cursive text on the screen continues. “The Obama admin. [sic] tried to blame the attack on a movie released on YouTube. Maybe they can try to blame Hurricane Sandy on one of those Al Gore movies.”

A movie poster from “The Day After Tomorrow,” a high-budget, special-effects driven disaster film from 2004, is shown in the background.

Consider the Source

Former Republican presidential candidate Rick Santorum speaks to reporters before the start of a bus tour campaign by Iowans for Freedom that is trying to convince Iowans to vote Iowa Supreme Court Justice David Wiggins off the bench.

AP

Right-wing groups attempt to dislodge justices in Florida, Iowa

By Chris Young

Conservative outside spending groups have taken to the airwaves in an attempt to kick four Supreme Court justices off the bench in Iowa and Florida for taking positions the groups find objectionable.

In Iowa, one organization, joined by former GOP presidential candidate Rick Santorum, hopes to oust a justice who supports same-sex marriage. In Florida, justices face the wrath of a pro-business group and a physician who object to President Barack Obama’s health care reform law.

Supporters of the justices have paid for ads and mailers and are defending the judges’ records while accusing their opponents of politicizing the court system.

The campaigns include television ads and dueling bus tours.

Eighteen states, including Iowa and Florida, require their appointed Supreme Court justices to periodically face voters in what are known as “merit retention elections.” Voters are asked whether a judge should remain on the bench. If a majority says no, the governor appoints new justices from a list of names submitted by a nonpartisan nominating commission.

Historically, retention elections generate little political spending and limited voter interest. From 2000 to 2009, retention elections accounted for about 1 percent of campaign spending on all state Supreme Court elections, according to Justice at Stake, a Washington, D.C.-based group critical of judicial elections.

In 2010, conservatives waged a successful campaign to oust three Iowa Supreme Court justices who voted the previous year to legalize gay marriage. Spending on retention elections that year jumped to roughly 13 percent of the total spent on all state Supreme Court elections.

The lone remaining justice in Iowa who voted with his ex-colleagues in supporting same-sex marriage has been targeted, as have three Florida justices.

Consider the Source

American Tradition Partnership attorney James Brown speaks to Helena, Mont., protesters angry with his client's anonymous political spending. ATP has successfully challenged several state campaign restrictions in court. The protesters are advocating a ballot initiative that declares corporations are not entitled to constitutional rights. 

Matt Gouras/AP

'Right-to-work' group gave Montana nonprofit $300,000

By Paul Abowd

A secretive nonprofit group that wants to nullify Montana’s campaign finance laws received a $300,000 donation from an anti-union organization aligned with a Colorado furniture executive, an Internal Revenue Service document shows.

American Tradition Partnership, a pro-energy group known for successfully suing Montana to force it to abide by the U.S. Supreme Court’s Citizens United ruling, has also sued the state to protect the identity of its donors — who have funded the ATP’s attack mailers in state races.

An IRS document obtained by the Center for Public Integrity indicates one of its early donors was a nonprofit 501(c)(4) called Coloradans for Economic Growth, which spent millions of dollars from undisclosed sources to support a failed 2008 ballot initiative that would have made Colorado a “right-to-work” state.

Among the initiative’s supporters was Jacob Jabs, president and CEO of American Furniture Warehouse. A 2008 letter to the IRS signed by former ATP employee Athena Dalton said Jabs was the “primary donor” and had promised to give $300,000 to ATP, but only if the IRS expedited its approval of ATP’s application for tax-exempt status.

Jabs has denied knowing anything about the group or giving it any money.

The appeal apparently worked. Three days later, the IRS approved the application.

ATP’s 2008 donors list shows a $300,000 contribution from Coloradans for Economic Growth, but makes no mention of any donation from Jabs.

Dalton did not return numerous calls. According to a report by ProPublica, a nonprofit news organization, Jabs said he contacted Dalton earlier this October and she told him that ATP officials had instructed her to use Jabs’ name in the letter.

Daily Disclosure

New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg

AP

Daily Disclosure: Bloomberg’s super PAC backs candidates in both parties

By Rachael Marcus

A super PAC founded by New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg reported spending $4.9 million on both Republicans and Democrats in Florida, Illinois and California, according to Federal Election Commission records filed Wednesday.

Independence USA PAC was formed Oct. 18, and voters won't know who its donors are until after the election. The group has spent $6 million so far this election.

The super PAC spent $2.5 million supporting the U.S. House run of California state Sen. Gloria Negrete McLeod, a Democrat; $1.8 million supporting the House run of former Orlando Chief of Police Val Demings, a Democrat; and $909,000 supporting Rep. Bob Dold, R-Ill., among other candidates.

The billionaire media mogul, now an independent, was a lifelong Democrat who switched to the GOP when he first ran for mayor.

He has pledged his super PAC will spend between $10 million and $15 million supporting state, local and congressional candidates who value bipartisanship and Bloomberg’s agenda, which includes supporting same-sex marriage, an overhaul of public schools, and his signature cause, gun control.

While Independence USA hasn't reported its donors, records show that a politically active nonprofit, Mayors Against Illegal Guns, is primarily supported by the mayor.

While Bloomberg has become increasingly involved in national politics this election, he had repeatedly declined to discuss the presidential election. He has expressed disappointment with both candidates. Today, he endorsed President Barack Obama.

Daily Disclosure

This Halloween-themed ad from the Congressional Leadership Fund opposes Rep. Kathy Hochul, D-N.Y.

YouTube/Screenshot

Daily Disclosure: Super PACs aim to spook voters with Halloween ads

By Rachael Marcus

Outside spenders are getting in the holiday spirit with Halloween-themed ads designed to scare voters away from the targeted candidates.

A foggy cemetery, a haunted house and shadowy figures loom in House Majority PAC’s ad, as the narrator speaks in a quivering voice pretending to be a ghost, explaining why voters should be afraid of Rep. Francisco “Quico” Canseco, the Republican candidate running in Texas’ 23rd District.

The narrator suddenly cuts the ghost voice and says, “This isn’t a Halloween story, though it is scary. It’s Quico Canseco’s — a person and a story that fits right into Washington.”

One of the ads main claims — that Canseco owes hundreds of thousands in liens over unpaid payroll taxes and contracting fees — was reported by the San Antonio Express-News in July 2010.

Canseco disputes the claim. He said the bulk of what is owed is a result of disagreements between contractors and tenants on properties he owns and that he was only named because he is the landlord.

Canseco faces Democratic challenger Pete Gallego, a Texas state representative. House Majority PAC’s Halloween ad is part of a $415,000 buy in Texas’ 23rd District, a Republican-leaning swing district.

The race has seen $6.6 million in outside spending, according to the Center for Responsive Politics.

Conservative spenders are also using the holiday to their advantage.

Pages

Writers and editors

John Dunbar

Managing Editor, Politics The Center for Public Integrity

John is director of Consider the Source, the Center's ongoing investigation of the impact of money on state and federal politic... More about John Dunbar

Michael Beckel

Reporter The Center for Public Integrity

Michael Beckel joined the Center for Public Integrity as a politics reporter in February 2012, where his focus is super PACs and the infl... More about Michael Beckel

Reity O'Brien

James R. Soles Fellow The Center for Public Integrity

Reity O’Brien is the Center’s 16th James R. Soles Fellow.... More about Reity O'Brien

Chris Young

American University Fellow The Center for Public Integrity

Chris Young is an American University Fellow currently working as a member of the Center’s Consider the Source team.... More about Chris Young

Dave Levinthal

Senior reporter The Center for Public Integrity

Dave Levinthal joined the Center for Public Integrity in 2013 to help lead its Consider the Source project investigating the influence of... More about Dave Levinthal

Ben Wieder

CAR Reporter The Center for Public Integrity

Ben Wieder is the Computer Assisted Reporter for the Consider the Sourc... More about Ben Wieder

Alison Fitzgerald

Senior reporter The Center for Public Integrity

Alison Fitzgerald is a finance and investigative reporter who joined the Center in April 2013 to help lead its financial reporting projec... More about Alison Fitzgerald

Alan Suderman

Reporter The Center for Public Integrity

Alan Suderman is a reporter for the Consider the Source project, where he focuses on the influence of money in state politics.... More about Alan Suderman

Dan Wagner

Reporter The Center for Public Integrity

Daniel Wagner came to the Center in 2013 from The Associated Press in Washington, D.C.... More about Dan Wagner